Poster Edges or Smudge Stick?
I'm trying to figure which Adobe Photoshop Elements filter I should use for my free canvas print — poster edges or smudge stick. Which photo do you think looks better on canvas?
Poster edges (left) and smudge stick (right) filters
Poster Edges Filter
Smudge Stick Filter
23 Comments
Leave a Comment
Subscribe to Daddy Forever
You can also sign up for Daddy Forever's blog feed.
I think Poster edges b/c the smudge completely whites out Disney's face. It is a hard pick though. Which does the wifey like?
.-= Susan Anderson´s last blog ..Bella's Six Month Cardiologist Appointment =-.
What? I'm suppose to consult with my wife instead of my readers?
Hmmmm crazy but I like the poster edges when it's smaller, and the smudge when it's larger. I'm no help.
Hugs,
Holly
.-= Holly Schwendiman´s last blog ..Signs of Growth =-.
I guess I won't know for sure until I actually see it on canvas. Then I'll probably second guess myself.
Holly has a point. I can't make up my mind. I still think Poor Little Disney is too whited out. Can they fix that? It kind of makes him look like… an Ewok? It just looks weird. For that reason alone I'd go with the Poster Edge. Well, except that in Poster Edge it makes him look like an old man who drew on hair. Smudge makes his hair look fuller. Oh just get both :P
I can play with the filters some more, but I'm not exactly a graphics artist.
Poster Edges. The smudge effect makes Disney's eyes look like holes. Is he shooting out laser beams at you?
.-= peepnroosmom´s last blog ..Just like Jack and the Beanstalk. =-.
No laser beams, but he usually gives me the finger when I try to feed him.
I prefer the poster edges. Filters can be a lot of fun! Happy WW! :D
.-= Dianne´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday – Blokus =-.
I like the most distinct so I can see their cute little faces. Smudged is too much like my reality
I like the first one better!
.-= Palabuzz´s last blog ..Sam Milby Poses for Folded and Hung =-.
Happy Holidays and have a great Wordless Wednesday!
http://www.momspective.com/chewy-chomp/
.-= Julie@Momspective´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday – Ba Chewy Chomp =-.
your children are just gorgeous!! i'm partial to the little girl! =)
Have you tried any others? These make the children's eyes look like holes.
.-= Mark´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday Forty-Three =-.
Those were the best ones. Maybe I should try a different program.
What great pictures of the kids! They are just adorable!
.-= Allison´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday: AAarrrgggghhh!!! #Meme =-.
I like the poster edges better. although I think a softer tough would be better if you can find it.
.-= Auntie E´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday-Festival of Trees =-.
Poster Edge is my preference. And I agree with Auntie E – a softer touch would be better. … your kids are adorable and the filters are getting in the way!! Best for the holidays.
.-= Lynn @Mama_Says´s last blog ..Wordless Wednesday =-.
I kind of luck the smudge one. But I see what folks mean about how your childrens' eyes look. Is there something a bit softer? Let us know what you choose to do. What beautiful babies you have!
.-= Newlyweds Guide Francesca´s last blog ..Holiday Thank You Cards for Your Wedding =-.
If I can't find a good effect, I'll go with an unfiltered photo. Since it's a canvas print, I thought a photo that didn't look like a photo would be better.
aww even on smudge they all look so adorable!
.-= mizhelle´s last blog ..Tagged: Friend Makin Wednesday =-.
Poster edges.
They're both so cute. I kind of like the smudge, but then I do worry about the eyes looking hollow. You might be able to find some online photo editors with more filters.
http://news.cnet.com/8301-17939_109-10170333-2.html
You might have already gotten it printed by now, but for the future, anyway!
.-= Lauren @ Hobo Mama´s last blog ..Flexibility and finding sleep =-.